British School Criticized for Alleged Under-reaction to Stabbing of 26 Students with a Needle

Some parents and students from the Toots School in Bingham, Notts are upset that a student who allegedly stabbed 26 other students with the same needle was only suspended for five days.  Administrators at the school apparently did not learn of the lunch-time attacks immediately and have defended their actions in not implementing a lockdown.  Head teacher John Tomasevic defended this decision stating ‘A lock down would have been an over-reaction and anyway by the time we’d even done our preliminary investigations the school day had finished so that wasn’t a possibility.’  Mr. Tomasevic told reporters that the student was involved in a game and that the attacks were not malicious.  Police have charged the 14-year-old student with suspicion of assault.  Some parents also complained that they were not notified by school officials about the incident.  Mr. Tomasevic told reporters that the school notified the parents of students who had been injured.

Students at the school are being tested for H.I.V. and parents are concerned that their children could become infected because so many students were stabbed with the same object which police identified as a lancet.  British public health officials indicate that the chances of a serious infection are not high. Multiple victim stabbings at schools are not unheard of with multiple incidents occurring in Japan and China with 28 victims in one attack in the People’s Republic of China.

Edged weapons attacks have become far more common in British schools in recent years with a number of fatalities of students and staff reported.  In an interview with British Metropolitan Police Officers in 2003, we learned that six students had been murdered at U.K. schools that year making the per capita homicide rate higher than for U.S. schools that year.

The response in the U.K. has been heavily geared to installing security cameras and issuing hand – held metal detectors for school officials to use to search students when they receive a tip that they might be carrying a weapon.  Searches of students for weapons by school officials have lead to a number of deaths and serious injuries in the United States and we advise our clients that this is an inherently dangerous practice.

This case illustrates the importance of proper student supervision.  The fact that school officials indicate that 26 children were attacked without school officials becoming aware immediately raises a red flag that student supervision may not have been effective.

Do Your Practices Match Your School Safety Plans?

One important aspect of school safety is how closely the written policies, procedures and plans reflect what is actually taking place in schools.  For example, a school safety incident is more likely to occur if good procedures are not followed.  This means that students, staff or visitors are more likely to be hurt.  In addition, these types of gaps can then expose school officials to increased exposure to school safety litigation and criticism from the media as well as a loss of public confidence. 

Having viable, well communicated and properly applied and enforced safety, security and emergency preparedness policies, plans and procedures can make school safer for all.

Wearing Staff Identification Cards Taken to a New Level

I found this to be a rather humorous exhibit at the Seattle Aquarium. This is however, a good reminder that it can be important for school staff to wear their photo ID cards. Wearing of ID cards by school staff can significantly enhance security in a school because it makes it easier for an intruder to be spotted. We have found that we are rarely detected when we conduct simulated security breaches in schools where some staff not wear their identification badge.

Providing School Safety and Security Notifications in Multiple Languages

School safety and security cautionary signage may need to be posted in multiple languages. This sign was photographed during a visit to an elementary school in South Africa.

Heroes Among us – Dr. Tina Brookes

She doesn’t have the cleanest car in town.  Her unrelenting schedule doesn’t really afford her the time to tidy it up like she should and probably desires.  Though she is not poor, she also doesn’t own the fanciest home in town.  Deciding to serve children doesn’t usually result in considerable wealth.  She may not have the most elegant office with a great view.  But she wouldn’t want that if they offered it to her.  This is because Dr. Tina Brookes is a true American hero.

I keep using the title of Dr. even though she has told me not to.  This is because I know how hard she worked to earn her Ph.D last year.  I imagine maintaining a 4.0 at one of North Carolina’s most respected universities was pretty tough too.  I do this also because I hold her in high regard as you may be able to tell by now.

I have known Dr. Brookes for some time now and worked with her on some pretty big projects.  I know that she has selflessly served others across our great land and in other countries when acts of violence, natural disasters and other tragedies have ripped the lives of beautiful children from their parents and tragically taken fathers and mothers from their young children.  I have seen how hard she works to try to address bullying, the threats of violence and the dangers posed by tornadoes in her communities’ schools.  I have seen her struggle with tragic loss in her personal life and have admired her strength as she uses her training, education and compassion to help others try to cope with similar losses.

But until I strained to read her dissertation through flowing tears, I did not fully comprehend what a hero Dr. Brookes really is.  I am still a bit miffed at her for not warning me about the power of her dissertation.  Getting real choked up from time to time on a flight from Atlanta to Seattle, I would have read her wonderful dissertation in the privacy of my own home had I had forewarning. But as a writer, I understand why she did not warn me and must admit it was better that she surprised me that way.  Dr. Brookes is not the kind of person you can stay mad at anyway. 

Her dissertation explored what happens when those who are trained in critical incident debriefing techniques help close friends and relatives cope with tragedy.  Reading her work reminded me of how easy and common it is for us to be in the company of amazing people and not realize it.  That is one of the things about life that has never ceased to amaze me.  Her dissertation reminded me of this once again.

I can forgive this truly amazing and outstanding woman for surprising me like this as long as she can forgive me for calling such a good friend Doctor.

Schools Should Have Crisis Plans in Place for Field Trips and Study Abroad Programs

Two recent incidents in New Zealand illustrate how quickly emergency situations can arise during student field trips.  While both of these recent incidents involve college students, many situations involving K-12 students have occurred as well.  

In the most recent incident, two American students became lost in a remote wilderness region during a snow storm.  Both survived the nine-day encounter.  Erica Klintworth and Alec Brown were participating in a foreign studies program through the University of Wisconsin Stevens Point.  Three university students from Boston were not so fortunate last month when they were killed during a vehicle accident in New Zealand.

In one Georgia case, two elementary students decided to run away from home during a field trip to Zoo Atlanta which is more than 90 miles from where they lived.  The students were finally located safely.   In another case in Alabama, a number of children along with a school bus driver and chaperone were killed in a school bus crash on a Saturday field trip.

As each of these incidents demonstrates, crisis planning concepts for schools and institutions of higher learning should be flexible enough to provide guidance for situations that occur far from school.