Fatalities from School Shootings Down, Lower Level Aggression Appears to be Increasing

The Twin Cities Press reported that a 17-year-old student attacked an 18-year veteran teacher and injured him badly enough to require transport to the hospital by ambulance. The teacher reportedly was cursed severely and then savagely attacked after instructing the student to remove headphones as required by school policy. Though not as horrific as an active shooter situation in a school there is an important aspect of this type of event. Many educators can relate something similar in a school they have taught or worked in if they have been in the field for more than ten years. Though fortunately, most of these incidents do not escalate quite to the level of this incident, verbal and physical attacks on school employees are disturbingly common in relation to many other types of school safety and security incidents.

While school shootings often dominate the media coverage for school safety topics, there has actually been a well-documented reduction in the per capita homicide rate on school property in the United States. There are a number of reasons this may be the case including:

• Improved emergency medical care

• The development of the multidisciplinary threat assessment approach for schools

• Improved school security and access control practices

• Increased utilization of weapons detection strategies such as random surprise metal detection, gun detection dogs, visual weapons screening and pattern matching and recognition

• An increased awareness among staff, students and parents about the dangers of school violence and the need to take school safety more seriously

• Improvements in policies relating to weapons on campus, violent behaviors and triggering behaviors such as fights

• The addition of thousands of school law enforcement officers in public and non public schools that previously did not have this valuable and effective resource

• Increased consistency in application of consequences for serious violations that can precede weapons use by students

• Improvements in school design

• Improvements in school climate

• Efforts to reduce bullying

• A variety of other techniques

While we still have much room for improvement, tremendous strides have been made and many gains achieved in our efforts to reduce weapons violence in our schools. At the same time, educators in many schools and districts often report a significant increase in lower level forms of aggression by students, parents and visitors. Though not a valid research approach, informal polling via a show of hands during keynote and training sessions for more than 50,000 attendees at my sessions in the past few years has revealed that a lot of hands go up when I ask people who have been in the field of education for more than ten years to raise their hands if they perceive significant increases in these types of behaviors. When I contrast the number of people in the room with those who keep their hands up when I ask about the perception that this type of behavior has increased, the overwhelming majority of attendees indicate that they do see a worsening in this area.

Though these types of events do not dominate the national news discussion relating to school safety and school performance, they have a very significant impact on both. I have met many former educators who have decided to change fields due to these types of incidents. Schools where reports of physical and verbal aggression are a regular type of event to any degree should work diligently to address this aspect of school safety. We have seen a number of schools successfully address lower level aggression through a comprehensive and thoughtful approach combining evidence based strategies with other techniques that are not as deeply rooted in solid research but have shown improvement nonetheless.

If lower level aggression is a regular problem in your schools, make it a priority to address this corrosive problem head on to reduce risk, reduce distraction in the classrooms, enhance the ability of children to learn and teachers to teach while making all safer.

Are Your School Employees Properly Empowered to Improve School Safety?

One thing we notice regularly in our school safety, security, climate, culture and emergency preparedness assessment work are opportunities to improve the level of empowerment of school employees to improve school safety. From preventive actions to life and death decision making, we regularly see significant gaps that relate to the empowerment of school employees to protect themselves and others.

We also often see this in school safety litigation work, unfortunately, this is often after someone has been seriously injured or killed and school safety related lawsuits have been filed. I recall a risk management instructor relating a case from Utah where a school district settled a case for millions of dollars after a student died from a medical emergency. In this truly extreme case, the district’s superintendent had put a policy in place that no one in the district could call 911 without his permission. This policy had apparently been implemented because the superintendent had been embarrassed when he could not respond to a reporter who asked him why police had been called to a school because he was not yet aware of the situation. When a student stopped breathing, there was an extended delay in calling for an ambulance while the superintendent was located.

While this is an extreme example, it is far from the most deadly. There have been other instances where the response by public safety officials was delayed while school employees tried to locate an administrator to make a life and death decision.

These deadly delays can be made less likely through proper planning, structure, training and most of all by clear empowerment of school staff that they can summon life-saving assistance or take action to otherwise save when it is appropriate.

Easy, Inexpensive and Effective – Improve Student Supervision to Enhance School Safety

 

Student supervision is one of the best ways to improve school safety

Students who are not being supervised in schools are more at risk

One of the most important aspects of school safety involves student supervision.

Effective student supervision practices reduce the risk of school safety incidents ranging from bullying, non-custodial abductions of students, sexual assaults on campus, weapons incidents, tornadoes and even terrorism. This is because improvements in student supervision are a powerful preventive measure while also being an important emergency preparedness tool.

For example, it is harder for someone to physically bully a student who is being closely supervised and it is not as easy to move students who are not being carefully supervised to safety if a tornado warning is received. One of the most common issues in school safety litigation involves student supervision. School safety expert witnesses are frequently asked to evaluate how much of an impact student supervision has had in a school safety incident.

Taking the time to focus on and properly address student supervision issues is time well spent.