There are people who purport that the school lockdown is a failed concept that is outdated and in dire need of replacement. This argument has not been established as a fact and is hotly contested by most leading experts in the field of school safety. When pressed for examples of where lockdown has failed in schools, proponents of abandoning school lockdown usually cite four instances:
- The library at Columbine High School which was actually never locked during the attack.
- The Virginia Tech shooting where lockdown was not in place as a protocol, practiced by the faculty and most rooms did not even have locks.
- The Sandy Hook Elementary School Shooting where we do not even know many the key facts of the case at this point and will not know them until the official report is released this summer.
- The Red Lake Reservation School Shooting which I worked as an expert witness finding only evidence no evidence of concept failure.
When evaluating school lockdown, we should be especially careful not to confuse application failure with concept failure. For example, if an aggressor is able to attack victims in a room because there is no viable lockdown protocol, staff do not have a key to the room they are teaching in, lockdown drills have not been conducted, etc. The cause can be and usually is from a failure to be able to apply the concept of school lockdown rather than a failure of the concept itself.
As an analogy, if I attempted to fly an F-22 Raptor jet, I would not be successful because I have not been trained or had the chance to practice flying one. This would not mean that the F-22 is a bad jet; it would simply mean that I am not properly prepared to fly one. After World War Two, military pilots were dying needlessly until the United States Air Force conducted an exhaustive study on ejection failures. By thoughtful study, the Air Force was able to determine why pilots were often unable to use the features of their aircraft to eject in time to save their lives. With a combined approach of modifications in plane design, training and practice, the Air Force was able to improve the application of emergency ejection and did not abandon the concept.
We respectfully submit that most of the problems we have seen with school lockdown do not indicate that this is a faulty concept, but instead that there is much evidence that many school staff are not properly prepared to apply the concepts under the stress of actual incidents.
Latest posts by Michael Dorn (see all)
- Free School Safety Conference Series, Presented by Navigate-Prepared - March 21, 2017
- South Carolina Advanced Emergency Management Training for School Districts Train the Trainer Program - March 2, 2017
- School Safety Support - February 22, 2017